By Julian Rothman
New York state governor Kathy Hochul has implemented a statewide ban on cell phone use in schools K-12. The law asserts that cell phone use within schools is prohibited during the school day, with possible exceptions regarding medical, education, and translation purposes. However, the Irvington Board of Education has voted that for anything other than certain approved medical reasons, there are no exceptions that should allow any students the use of their cell phones. This outcome has received an array of responses from staff and, primarily, students.
As of the start of the school year, the controversial phone ban has been deeply affecting the work lives of Irvington High School students as they must adapt to a new cell phone free environment. Students have had mixed opinions, as we can see with these three high schoolers giving their own two cents on the new state law.
Most of the students interviewed were starkly against the decision: “We were already interacting with each other, and now I feel like it’s limiting our opportunities as students.” – Emmet Grayson 10th grader.
And he isn’t alone in his stance: “We’re responsible people, I think we should be able to use our phones during our free period. The phone ban is excessive,” says senior Haden Kwon. However, it’s important to note that not everyone is against the ban; some agree with the claims that a lack of cellular devices improves student connection and class focus.
“My opinion on the phone ban is that it is not the best but it does have good outcomes. It makes basic human interaction better, and it also makes it so people are less distracted, and it makes things more peaceful,” said 10th grader Oliver van der Spuy.
And so, clear opinions aren’t unanimous amongst the student population, and by all accounts, this new law is here to stay. Whether for better or for worse, that’s for you to decide.
Comments are closed.